Guide to Writing a
Basic Essay
Basic Guide to
Essay Writing
Created by Kathy
Livingston (lklivingston@mindspring.com). All rights reserved.
Not to be
distributed without the permission of the author.
An essay can have many purposes, but
the basic structure is the same no matter what. You may be writing an essay to
argue for a particular point of view or to explain the steps necessary to
complete a task. Either way, your essay will have the same basic format. If you
follow a few simple steps, you will find that the essay almost writes itself.
You will be responsible only for supplying ideas, which are the important part
of the essay anyway. Don't let the thought of putting pen to paper daunt you.
Get started!
These simple steps will guide you
through the essay writing process:
- Decide on your topic.
- Prepare an outline or diagram of your ideas.
- Write your thesis statement.
- Write the body.
- Write the main points.
- Write the subpoints.
- Elaborate on the subpoints.
- Write the introduction.
- Write the conclusion.
- Add the finishing touches.
Choose a Topic
for Your Essay
Topic Has Been
Assigned
You may have no choice as to your
topic. If this is the case, you still may not be ready to jump to the next
step. Think about the type of paper you are expected to produce. Should it be a
general overview, or a specific analysis of the topic? If it should be an
overview, then you are probably ready to move to the next step. If it should be
a specific analysis, make sure your topic is fairly specific. If it is too
general, you must choose a narrower subtopic to discuss. For example, the topic
"KENYA"
is a general one. If your objective is to write an overview, this topic is
suitable. If your objective is to write a specific analysis, this topic is too
general. You must narrow it to something like "Politics in Kenya" or "Kenya's Culture." Once you
have determined that your topic will be suitable, you can move on.
Topic Has Not
Been Assigned
If you have not been assigned a
topic, then the whole world lies before you. Sometimes that seems to make the
task of starting even more intimidating. Actually, this means that you are free
to choose a topic of interest to you, which will often make your essay a
stronger one.
Define Your Purpose
The first thing you must do is think
about the purpose of the essay you must write. Is your purpose to persuade people
to believe as you do, to explain to people how to complete a particular task,
to educate people about some person, place, thing or idea, or something else
entirely? Whatever topic you choose must fit that purpose.
Brainstorm Subjects of Interest
Once
you have determined the purpose of your essay, write down some subjects that
interest you. No matter what the purpose of your essay is, an endless number of
topics will be suitable. If you have trouble thinking of subjects, start by
looking around you. Is there anything in your surroundings that interests you?
Think about your life. What occupies most of your time? That might make for a
good topic. Don't evaluate the subjects yet; just write down anything that
springs to mind. Evaluate Each Potential Topic If you can think of at least a
few topics that would be appropriate, you must simply consider each one
individually.
Think
about how you feel about that topic. If you must educate, be sure it is a
subject about which you are particularly well-informed. If you must persuade,
be sure it is a subject about which you are at least moderately passionate. Of
course, the most important factor in choosing a topic is the number of ideas
you have about that topic. Even if none of the subjects you thought of seem
particularly appealing, try just choosing one to work with. It may turn out to
be a better topic than you at first thought. Before you are ready to move on in
the essay-writing process, look one more time at the topic you have selected.
Think
about the type of paper you are expected to produce. Should it be a general
overview, or a specific analysis of the topic? If it should be an overview,
then you are probably ready to move to the next step. If it should be a
specific analysis, make sure your topic is fairly specific. If it is too
general, you must choose a narrower subtopic to discuss. For example, the topic
"KENYA"
is a general one. If your objective is to write an overview, this topic is suitable.
If your objective is to write a specific analysis, this topic is too general.
You must narrow it to something like "Politics in Kenya" or "Kenya's Culture." Once you
have determined that your topic will be suitable, you can move on.
Organize Your Ideas
The
purpose of an outline or diagram is to put your ideas about the topic on paper,
in a moderately organized format. The structure you create here may still
change before the essay is complete, so don't agonize over this. Decide whether
you prefer the cut-and-dried structure of an outline or a more flowing
structure. If you start one or the other and decide it isn't working for you,
you can always switch later.
Diagram
- Begin your diagram with a circle or a horizontal line or whatever shape you prefer in the middle of the page.
- Inside the shape or on the line, write your topic.
- From your center shape or line, draw three or four lines out into the page. Be sure to spread them out.
- At the end of each of these lines, draw another circle or horizontal line or whatever you drew in the center of the page.
- In each shape or on each line, write the main ideas that you have about your topic, or the main points that you want to make. If you are trying to persuade, you want to write your best arguments. If you are trying to explain a process, you want to write the steps that should be followed. You will probably need to group these into categories. If you have trouble grouping the steps into categories, try using Beginning, Middle, and End. If you are trying to inform, you want to write the major categories into which your information can be divided.
- From each of your main ideas, draw three or four lines out into the page.
- At the end of each of these lines, draw another circle or horizontal line or whatever you drew in the centerof the page.
- In each shape or on each line, write the facts or information that support that main idea. When you have finished, you have the basic structure for your essay and are ready to continue.
Outline
1.
Begin
your outline by writing your topic at the top of the page.
2.
Next,
write the Roman numerals I, II, and III, spread apart down the left side of the
page.
3.
Next
to each Roman numeral, write the main ideas that you have about your topic, or
the main points that you want to make. If you are trying to persuade, you want
to write your best arguments. If you are trying to explain a process, you want
to write the steps that should be followed. You will probably need to group
these into categories. If you have trouble grouping the steps into categories,
try using Beginning, Middle, and End. If you are trying to inform, you want to
write the major categories into which your information can be divided.
4.
Under
each Roman numeral, write A, B, and C down the left side of the page.
5.
Next
to each letter, write the facts or information that support that main idea.
When
you have finished, you have the basic structure for your essay and are ready to
continue.
Compose a Thesis
Statement
Now
that you have decided, at least tentatively, what information you plan to
present in your essay, you are ready to write your thesis statement. The thesis
statement tells the reader what the essay will be about, and what point you,
the author, will be making. You know what the essay will be about. That was
your topic. Now you must look at your outline or diagram and decide what point
you will be making. What do the main ideas and supporting ideas that you listed
say about your topic? Your thesis statement will have two parts.
The first part states the topic.
- Kenya's Culture
- Building a Model Train Set
- Public Transportation
The second part states the point of the
essay.
- has a rich and varied history
- takes time and patience
- can solve some of our city's most persistent and pressing problems
Once you have formulated a thesis
statement that fits this pattern and with which you are comfortable, you are
ready to continue.
Write the Body
Paragraphs
In the body of
the essay, all the preparation up to this point comes to fruition. The topic
you have chosen must now be explained, described, or argued. Each main idea
that you wrote down in your diagram or outline will become one of the body
paragraphs. If you had
three or four
main ideas, you will have three or four body paragraphs. Each body paragraph
will have the same basic structure.
- Start by writing down one of your main ideas, in sentence form. If your main idea is "reduces freeway congestion," you might say this: Public transportation reduces freeway congestion.
- Next, write down each of your supporting points for that main idea, but leave four or five lines in between each point.
- In the space under each point, write down some elaboration for that point.
- Elaboration can be further description or explanation or discussion.
Supporting Point
Commuters appreciate the cost
savings of taking public transportation rather than driving.
Elaboration
Less driving
time means less maintenance expense, such as oil changes. Of course, less
driving time means savings on gasoline as well. In many cases, these savings
amount to more than the cost of riding public transportation. If you wish,
include a summary sentence for each paragraph. This is not generally needed,
however, and such sentences have a tendency to sound stilted, so be cautious about
using them. Once you have fleshed out each of your body paragraphs, one for
each main point, you are ready to continue.
Write the
Introduction and Conclusion
Your essay lacks only two paragraphs
now: the introduction and the conclusion. These paragraphs will give the reader
a point of entry to and a point of exit from your essay.
Introduction
The introduction should be designed
to attract the reader's attention and give her an idea of the essay's focus.
1. Begin with an attention grabber.
The attention
grabber you use is up to you, but here are some ideas:
- Startling information
This information
must be true and verifiable, and it doesn't need to be totally new to your
readers. It could simply be a pertinent fact that explicitly illustrates the
point you wish to make. If you use a piece of startling information, follow it
with a sentence or two of elaboration.
- Anecdote
An anecdote is a
story that illustrates a point.
Be sure your
anecdote is short, to the point, and relevant to your topic. This can be a very
effective opener for your essay, but use it carefully.
- Dialogue
An appropriate
dialogue does not have to identify the speakers, but the reader must understand
the point you are trying to convey. Use only two or three exchanges between
speakers to make your point. Follow dialogue with a sentence or two of
elaboration.
- Summary Information
A few sentences
explaining your topic in general terms can lead the reader gently to your
thesis.
Each sentence
should become gradually more specific, until you reach your thesis.
2. If the
attention grabber was only a sentence or two, add one or two more sentences
that will lead the reader from your opening to your thesis statement.
3. Finish the
paragraph with your thesis statement.
Conclusion
The conclusion
brings closure to the reader, summing up your points or providing a final
perspective on your topic. All the conclusion needs is three or four strong
sentences which do not need to follow any set formula. Simply review the main
points (being careful not to restate them exactly) or briefly describe your
feelings about the topic. Even an anecdote can end your essay in a useful way. The
introduction and conclusion complete the paragraphs of your essay. Don't stop
just yet! One more step remains before your essay is truly finished.
Add the
Finishing Touches
You have now
completed all of the paragraphs of your essay. Before you can consider this a
finished product, however, you must give some thought to the formatting of your
paper.
Check the order
of your paragraphs.
Look at your
paragraphs. Which one is the strongest? You might want to start with the
strongest paragraph, end with the second strongest, and put the weakest in the
middle. Whatever order you decide on, be sure it makes sense. If your paper is
describing a process, you will probably need to stick to the order in which the
steps must be completed.
Check the
instructions for the assignment.
When you prepare
a final draft, you must be sure to follow all of the instructions you have been
given.
- Are your margins correct?
- Have you titled it as directed?
- What other information (name, date, etc.) must you include?
- Did you double-space your lines?
Check your
writing.
Nothing can
substitute for revision of your work. By reviewing what you have done, you can
improve weak points that otherwise would be missed. Read and reread your paper.
- Does it make logical sense? Leave it for a few hours and then read it again. Does it still make logical sense?
- Do the sentences flow smoothly from one another? If not, try to add some words and phrases to help connect them. Transition words, such as "therefore" or "however," sometimes help. Also, you might refer in one sentence to a thought in the previous sentence. This is especially useful when you move from one paragraph to another.
How to Write an Essay: 10 Easy Steps
I found myself beset by so many doubts and errors that I came to
think I had gained nothing from my attempts to become educated but increasing
recognition of my ignorance.
Rene Descartes
Rene Descartes
Why
is writing an essay so frustrating?
Learning how to write an essay can
be a maddening, exasperating process, but it doesn't have to be. If you know
the steps and understand what to do, writing can be easy and even fun.
This site, "How To Write an
Essay: 10 Easy Steps," offers a ten-step process that teaches students
how to write an essay. Links to the writing steps are found on the left, and
additional writing resources are located across the top.
|
Learning
how to write an essay doesn't have to involve so much trial and error.
|
Brief Overview of the 10 Essay Writing Steps
Below
are brief summaries of each of the ten steps to writing an essay. Select the
links for more info on any particular step, or use the blue navigation bar on
the left to proceed through the writing steps. How To Write an Essay can
be viewed sequentially, as if going through ten sequential steps in an essay
writing process, or can be explored by individual topic.
1. Research:
Begin the essay writing process by
researching your topic, making yourself an expert. Utilize the internet, the
academic databases, and the library. Take notes and immerse yourself in the
words of great thinkers.
2.
Analysis:
Now that you have a good knowledge base, start analyzing the arguments of the
essays you're reading. Clearly define the claims, write out the reasons, the
evidence. Look for weaknesses of logic, and also strengths. Learning how to write an essay begins by learning how to analyze
essays written by others.
3.
Brainstorming:
Your essay will require insight of your own, genuine essay-writing brilliance.
Ask yourself a dozen questions and answer them. Meditate with a pen in your
hand. Take walks and think and think until you come up with original insights
to write about.
4.
Thesis: Pick
your best idea and pin it down in a clear assertion that you can write your
entire essay around. Your thesis is your main point, summed up in a concise
sentence that lets the reader know where you're going, and why. It's practically
impossible to write a good essay without a clear thesis.
5.
Outline:
Sketch out your essay before straightway writing it out. Use one-line sentences
to describe paragraphs, and bullet points to describe what each paragraph will
contain. Play with the essay's order. Map out the structure of your argument,
and make sure each paragraph is unified.
6.
Introduction:
Now sit down and write the essay. The introduction should grab the reader's
attention, set up the issue, and lead in to your thesis. Your intro is merely a
buildup of the issue, a stage of bringing your reader into the essay's
argument.
(Note: The title and first paragraph are probably the most
important elements in your essay. This is an essay-writing point that doesn't
always sink in within the context of the classroom. In the first paragraph you
either hook the reader's interest or lose it. Of course your teacher, who's
getting paid to teach you how to write an essay, will read the essay you've
written regardless, but in the real world, readers make up their minds about
whether or not to read your essay by glancing at the title alone.)
7.
Paragraphs:
Each individual paragraph should be focused on a single idea that supports your
thesis. Begin paragraphs with topic sentences, support assertions with
evidence, and expound your ideas in the clearest, most sensible way you can.
Speak to your reader as if he or she were sitting in front of you. In other
words, instead of writing the essay, try talking the essay.
8.
Conclusion:
Gracefully exit your essay by making a quick wrap-up sentence, and then end on
some memorable thought, perhaps a quotation, or an interesting twist of logic,
or some call to action. Is there something you want the reader to walk away and
do? Let him or her know exactly what.
9.
MLA Style:
Format your essay according to the correct guidelines for citation. All
borrowed ideas and quotations should be correctly cited in the body of your
text, followed up with a Works Cited (references) page listing the details of
your sources.
10.
Language:
You're not done writing your essay until you've polished your language by
correcting the grammar, making sentences flow, incoporating rhythm, emphasis,
adjusting the formality, giving it a level-headed tone, and making other
intuitive edits. Proofread until it reads just how you want it to sound.
Writing an essay can be tedious, but you don't want to bungle the hours of
conceptual work you've put into writing your essay by leaving a few slippy
misppallings and pourly wordedd phrazies..
You're
done. Great job. Now move over Ernest Hemingway — a new writer is coming of
age! (Of course Hemingway was a fiction writer, not an essay writer, but he
probably knew how to write an essay just as well.)
My Promise: The Rest of This Site Will Really Teach You How
To Write an Essay
For half a dozen years I've read thousands of college essays
and taught students how to write essays, do research, analyze arguments, and so
on. I wrote this site in the most basic, practical way possible and made the
instruction crystal clear for students and instructors to follow. If you
carefully follow the ten steps for writing an essay as outlined on this site —
honestly and carefully follow them — you'll learn how to write an essay that is
more organized, insightful, and appealing. And you'll probably get an A.
Now it's
time to really begin. C'mon, it will be fun. I promise to walk you through each
step of your writing journey.
Step 1: Research
- Assuming you've been given a topic, or have narrowed it sufficiently down, your first task is to research this topic. You will not be able to write intelligently about a topic you know nothing about. To discover worthwhile insights, you'll have to do some patient reading.
- Read light sources, then thorough
- When you conduct research, move from light to thorough resources to make sure you're moving in the right direction. Begin by doing searches on the Internet about your topic to familiarize yourself with the basic issues; then move to more thorough research on the Academic Databases; finally, probe the depths of the issue by burying yourself in the library. Make sure that despite beginning on the Internet, you don't simply end there. A research paper using only Internet sources is a weak paper, and puts you at a disadvantage for not utilizing better information from more academic sources.
- Write down quotations
- As you read about your topic, keep a piece of paper and pen handy to write down interesting quotations you find. Make sure you write down the source and transcribe quotations accurately. I recommend handwriting the quotations to ensure that you don't overuse them, because if you have to handwrite the quotations, you'll probably only use quotations sparingly, as you should. On the other hand, if you're cruising through the net, you may just want to cut and paste snippets here and there along with their URLs into a Word file, and then later go back and sift the kernels from the chaff.
- With print sources, you might put a checkmark beside interesting passages. Write questions or other thoughts in the margins as well. If it's a library book, use post-it notes to avoid ruining the book. Whatever your system, be sure to annotate the text you read. If reading online, see if you can download the document, and then use Word's Reviewing toolbar to add notes or the highlighter tool to highlight key passages.
- Take a little from a lot
- You'll need to read widely in order to gather sources on your topic. As you integrate research, take a little from a lot -- that is, quote briefly from a wide variety of sources. This is the best advice there is about researching. Too many quotations from one source, however reliable the source, will make your essay seem unoriginal and borrowed. Too few sources and you may come off sounding inexperienced. When you have a lot of small quotations from numerous sources, you will seem -- if not be -- well-read, knowledgeable, and credible as you write about your topic.
- If you're having trouble with research, you may want to read this Research FAQ.
Step 1a: Researching on the Internet
|
|
While the Internet should never be your only source of information, it would be ridiculous not to utlize its vast sources of information. You should use the Internet to acquaint yourself with the topic more before you dig into more academic texts. When you search online, remember a few basics:
Use a variety of
search engines
The
Internet contains some 550 billion web pages. Google is a powerful search
engine, but it only reaches about 5 billion of those pages -- less than one
percent! When you search the Internet, you should use a handful of different
search engines. The Academic Search Engines above (collected mostly from Paula
Dragutsky's Searchability)
specialize in delivering material more suitable for college purposes, while the
Popular Search Engines help locate information on less academic topics.
Whatever your topic, use a variety of search engines from both menus.
Once you go beyond Google, you will begin to realize the limitlessness horizons
of the Internet. For example, a searchstring on www.wisenut.com results in hits different from www.turbo10.com, which also
results in different hits on www.google.com
and www.overture.com. Try
it!
Look at the Site's
Quality
With
all the returns from your searches, you'll doubtless pull in a bundle of sites,
and like a fisherman on a boat, your job will be to sort through the trash. The
degree of professional design and presentation of a site should speak somewhat
towards the content. Sites with black backgrounds are usually entertainment
sites, while those with white backgrounds are more information based. Sites
with colorful and garish backgrounds are probably made by novice designers.
Avoid blog pages (online journals). Avoid "free-essay" pages. Avoid
pages where there are multiple applets flashing on the screen. Also pay
attention to the domain types. You should know that:
- .com = commercial
- .org = organization
- .gov = government
- .edu = education
- .net = network
The
domain type indicates a possible bias toward the information. Obviously an .org
site on animal rights is going to be a bit slanted towards one side of the
issue. And if the sites try to sell you something, like many of the
"sponsored listings" that appear on the top of the hits list with
search engines, avoid them.
Mix up your search words
If
you're getting too many hits, enter more keywords in the search box. If you
aren't getting enough hits, enter fewer keywords in the searchbox. Also try
inputting the same concept but in different words and phrases. Overture has a keyword search suggestion tool that lets you know what the
most popular search strings are for the concept you're searching for. Search
Engine Watch also has a
useful tutorial on how to enter search strings, explaining how to add + and
- and quotation marks to get more accurate results.
Many
search engines have advanced tabs that help you search with more detail.
Google, for example, has an advanced search option that greatly increases
accuracy of returns, though few use it. Finally, know that some search engines
specialize in specific types of content, so if you don't have much success with
one search engine, try another.
Don't Limit Yourself to
the Internet
While
it's fun to surf the net and discover new sites with information relevant to
your topic, don't limit yourself to the Internet. By and large the Internet,
because it is a medium open to publication by all, can contain some pretty
sketchy information. If your essay is backed by research from "Steve and
Kim's homepage," "Matt's Econ Blog," and
"teenstuffonline," your essay won't be as convincing as it would be
with more academic journals. Academic journals and books have better research,
more thorough treatment of the topics, a more stable existence (they'll still
be there in a 10 years), and ultimately more persuasive power. Don't substitute
Eddy Smith's "Summer Vacation to the Middle East"
for Edward Said's Orientalism.
Step 1b: Researching the Academic Databases
The Academic Databases
Almost every college subscribes to a
list of academic databases where more specialized, academic essays can be
found. If you are an AUC student, go to the AUC Library Homepage and choose Electronic
Resources to survey the 80+ academic databases that AUC subscribes to. Each
of these databases specializes in a different kind of information. For a
writing class exploring general research topics, the following four indexes are
probably the most useful:
·
JSTOR
(Note that at AUC, in order to
search the databases from your home, you will need to request a dial-in account so
that you can dial in directly to the AUC server. Otherwise, you must use a
campus computer lab to access these databases.)
|
Academic
Search Premier is the most popular student database, and the most costly for
schools. It is one of a handful of databases on EBSCO Host. After selecting
Academic Search Premier, you will see a screen allowing you to specify more
databases within EBSCO Host. Depending upon your topic, you may also want to
check some of these boxes. On the search query screen on Academic Search
Premier, you can control the kind of return hits your search retrieves.
On
the Advanced Search tab, you can also search for keywords within a specific
publication. This would be helpful if you knew a good journal or magazine, but
were unsure of when an article was published on the topic in it.
CQ Researcher is a bit different than other journals. Every two weeks a
new issue dedicated solely to one hot, current issue is published. One or two
researchers produce all the content, and the articles are mainly informational
rather than argumentative, giving readers an overview of the issue, of pro/con
debates, a history, a bibliography of sources, and so on. CQ Researcher's
bibliography is a great source for finding more sources -- you can plug some of
the titles into other academic databases or even the Internet itself and often
find the source. Because CQ Researcher is single-authored, you should
careful that you do not overquote from it.
To
cite a source from CQ Researcher, click on the nifty CiteNow! link on the top toolbar of the article and
select MLA style.
A
more academic journal, JSTOR has its articles stored as .pdf files. These
.pds files can sometimes be large and therefore take a long time to download.
However, all articles within the JSTOR database are quality academic
articles, some perhaps beyond the scope of what you're looking for. To read a
.pdf file you must have Adobe Acrobat reader, which you can download for free
if your computer doesn't already have it. Before you search on JSTOR,
you must first select which journals you want to search in.
The most common complaint students
have about JSTOR is that the essays are too long and difficult to read. In
fact, reading from JSTOR in contrast to the Internet will give you a good feel
for the difference between academic and non-academic sources. When you use a
source from JSTOR in your essay, your essay will be much more credible and
scholarly.
If
you're looking for news articles, LEXIS-NEXIS is the database to search.
Keep in mind, though, that news articles aren't usually scholarly articles;
they mostly give current information about topics. Some of the longer articles
on LEXIS-NEXIS may be more scholarly. You just have to judge by the depth and
research in the essay. The LEXIS-NEXIS database seems to contain almost every
newspaper in the world. Hence specifying the search queries to get the returns
you want can be a bit more complicated than usual.
First, select guided Guided News Search.
In
the Guided News Search tab (rather than the "Quick News Search" tab)
follow the four steps for making a more specific selection. Doing so will yield
much better results than simply typing in general keywords into the Quick News
Search.
Troubleshooting
If
you're having trouble finding information on one database, try another. Mix up
your keywords or use different ones. If you get too many hits, try searching
with more specific keywords. If you don't get enough hits, search with a
broader set of keywords, or even just one keyword.
Finally,
remember that you are not limited to these four databases. There are dozens
more that the library subscribes to. Scan down the list and see if any others
might be useful. These five are perhaps worth checking out:
- ERIC (EBSCOHost)
- Oxford English Dictionary
- Project Muse
- Sociological Abstracts
- WorldCat
Step 1c: Researching in the Library
A
common misconception among students is that the library is full of old,
out-of-date, musty books -- probably none from this century -- and therefore
any books found there would be so out of step with the current discussion on
the topic that the books, and any effort to retrieve them, would be utterly
useless.
Fortunately,
all libraries have acquisitions departments with specialists from
different fields of scholarship who constantly order up-to-date books on the
contemporary issues in almost all fields. As a result, most libraries have
books on all issues at least within the last ten years or so. So unless you're
writing about something totally new, chances are a book has been written on it,
and most likely that book is waiting for you in the library.
Retrieving
books saves energy
Another
misconception many students have is that even if they were to see a book listed
on the electronic catalogs, it would be too much of a hassle to physically go
to the library, hike the stairs, take elevators perhaps, wander among the
stacks and corridors, skim through eternal Library of Congress call numbers,
and so on.
While
it is true that the physical exertion required (i.e., walking) to find the book
is more than that required to click a mouse, once you find the book, it
requires less energy to progress through the information than it does to fight
the endless screens, non-linear progressions, and specious content on the
Internet. In contrast, books are well-organized, logically progressive texts
that usually contain abundant research, are written by scholars, and will
provide excellent evidence for your essay.
The
Internet is full of everything from porno to CIA reports, and it's all jumbled
together like paint splattered on a wall. You'll have to sort through it like a
homeless man foraging for food in a dumpster. Think about how nice it would be
instead to read a chapter from a book while lying in bed.
Learn
to skim books
Because
books are so thorough and long (it may have taken the author years to write it,
as opposed to an online article, which might have been written in under an
hour), you have to learn to skim. Skim the table of contents to see if there is
a chapter that is relevant. Read the introduction and the first pages of
several chapters to see if the information is really what you're looking for.
Since
you will still need to cite from a variety of sources, don't spend too long
immersed in the same book. Take a little information from a lot of different
books -- from an author here, an author there. It might be a good idea to
photocopy the necessary pages rather than cart around a backpack full of books.
Library
as sanctuary
The
more you spend time researching in the library, the more you will come to see
what a sanctuary the library can be. The loud, noisy traffic of the streets
outside is blocked out as you sit comfortably surrounded by thousands of
insightful books on important topics throughout the ages. A library can be a
sanctuary to you -- a place to study, a place to escape your friends or other
obligations, a refuge of peace and quiet. A good library is the heart of any
academic institution, and the more time you spend in it, the more it will feel
like hallowed ground. One student at New
York University
even decided to sleep permanently in his university's library
(only superficially for financial reasons).
Step 2: Analysis
As
you research your topic, you will naturally be analyzing the arguments of
different authors. In contrast to more popular reading, in the academic world,
authors must supply copious amounts of evidence and nuanced reasoning in order
persuade other scholars of their ideas. To enter the scholar's "gladiator
arena," you will need to understand the principles of argument. Both
analyzing an argument and coming up with your own will require careful thought.
Identify
the argument
An
argument consists of two main components: a claim, and reasons for that claim.
Neither a claim without reasons, nor reasons without a claim, is an argument.
Only when one leverages particular reasons to make a claim from those reasons
do we say that an "argument" is taking place.
When
analyzing an argument of any text, or creating one of your own, first identify
the main claim and then locate all the reasons for it. The claim is the
controversial, debatable assertion of the essay, while the reasons offer the
explanations and evidence of why the claim is true. It is helpful to map this
reasoning out:
CLAIM
= ________________________________________
·
Reason 1:
____________________________
·
Reason 2:
____________________________
·
Reason 3:
____________________________
Assess
the reasoning
Once
you have the argument mapped out, assess the reasoning. Ask yourself the
following questions to help you identify weaknesses of logic:
(1.)
Is there an alternative explanation that is possible? An alternative
explanation is a different reason for the same claim. Probing the
alternative explanations or reasons for a claim is an excellent way to open up
weaknesses in the author's logic.
- Example: "John was late because he obviously doesn't care about the class." (An alternative explanation for John's lateness could be that he got in a car wreck, and therefore couldn't make it on time to class, not that he doesn't care about it.)
(2.) Is the evidence presented
sufficient? Evidence refers to the support given for a claim. This
support may be in the form of facts, statistics, authoritative quotations,
studies, observations, experiences, research, or other forms of proof.
- Example: "John was late because he has Alzheimer's disease, and according to the American Medical Association, Alzheimer's patients frequently forgot who and where they are" (Jones 65). (The writer has given evidence in the form of research for his or her reasoning.)
(3.)
What assumptions do the reasons rest on? An assumption is what one takes for
granted to be true, but which actually may not be true. All arguments rest on
some common assumptions. This common ground makes it possible for two people to
have a dialogue in the first place, but these assumptions, because they are
based on groundless ideas, make for a "sweet spot" of attack in
argument.
- Example: "John was late because his previous class is on the far side of campus." (The assumption is that it takes a long time to get from the far side of campus to class. If John walked the same speed as the one presenting the argument, the assumption would be a shared one. However, it may be the case that John actually walks much faster than assumed, and that he was late for another reason.)
Either/Or:
Narrowing the options to just two
extremes when in actuality more options exist.
o Example: Either
John was late because he forgot where the class was, or because he didn't
want to come. (Actually, John may have been late for another reason not
listed here. Maybe he fell down a manhole.)
o Example:
Either spend the entire night proofreading your paper or you will get an F in
the course. (Actually, you might ask the teacher for a one day extension so
that you don't have to kill yourself with an all-nighter. The point is that
there aren't just two options.)
|
Non
Sequitar: The conclusion/claim doesn't
follow from the reasons.
o Example:
I saw John talking to a pretty girl this morning. Therefore, he is late to
class because he's probably eating lunch with her. (It doesn't follow that
talking to a pretty girl would lead to a truant luncheon.)
o Example:
Some cars drive recklessly along the roads where pedestrians walk,
endangering them. Therefore, we should ban pedestrians from walking down some
roads. (It doesn't follow that you should punish the pedestrians instead of
the cars.)
|
Slippery
Slope: Exaggerating the consequences.
o Example:
If John is late to class, he'll miss the material and do poorly on the test.
When his father sees his bad grades, John will be whipped and then he'll run
away and join the circus. (Actually, John may do fine on the test even though
he missed class.)
o Example:
Students who arrive late to class will receive low grades, which will then
prevent them from declaring their majors. If students can't declare the
majors they want, they'll lead miserable lives fulfilling careers they hate
until they finally commit suicide. (Actually, even if students receive a low
grade, it doesn't mean they won't be able to bring up their other grades in
other classes and still declare the majors they want.)
|
Fallacy
of Authority: Accepting for truth what is
claimed simply because someone said so.
o Example:
John was late to class because his the school psychologist said John was
having bouts of depression and may not attend class. (Actually, what the
psychologist said may be wrong. Maybe John even lied to her.)
o Example:
John Grisham, an expert in law, says law is a tedious yet exciting practice.
So it must be the case that law is a tedious, exciting practice. (Actually,
what Grisham says may not be true. He hasn't supplied any reasoning for his
assertion, and he's a popular fiction writer rather than a lawyer.)
|
Faulty
Cause and Effect: Attributing the wrong cause to
the effect.
o Example:
John was late to class because he
went to the dentist yesterday and had a root canal. (Actually, John may be
late for another reason.)
o Example:
The horses are acting strange because there's a deep storm brewing.
(Actually, the horses may be acting strange because they're hungry.)
|
Hasty
Generalization: Generalizing from a sample that is
too small.
o Example:
John was late to my physics class all last semester. Therefore John is just
an unpunctual, late person. (Actually, last semester John may have had
difficulty getting to physics, but no trouble getting to his other classes.)
o Example: I
conclude from the several pleasant, hard-working AUC students I met this
morning that all AUC students are pleasant, hard-working students. (Actually,
you may have just met the only three nice students on campus.)
|
Select
a fallacy above to see an explanation of it in this window.
|
(4.) Does the writer commit any
logical fallacies? Fallacies are commonly committed errors of reasoning. Being
aware of these fallacies will help you see them more abundantly in the texts
you read. Although there are probably at least a hundred different fallacies,
the following six are the most common:
- Hasty Generalization
- Faulty Cause and Effect
- Fallacy of Authority
- Slippery Slope
- Non Sequitar
- Either/Or
Step 3: Brainstorming
Find
an original idea
Brainstorming
is the art of thinking critically to discover original, hidden insights about a
topic. Assuming you've done a fair amount of research, you should now have a
solid base of concepts to play around with for an essay. The task is now to
stand on the shoulders of the scholars you've read and find something
original to say about the topic. It is not enough to regurgitate what they
have said. You must go beyond them to propose an original idea. Your paper
should expose some new idea or insight about the topic, not just be a collage
of other scholars' thoughts and research -- although you will definitely rely
upon these scholars as you move toward your point.
Use
different techniques
Since
the days of Aristotle, a variety of "invention techniques" or
"heuristics" have been used for coming up with ideas. Depending on
your topic, some invention techniques may work better than others. The overall
goal when using any method is to discover unique ideas that take you and your
reader beyond the obvious. The following wheel briefly describes nine of the
most common methods for finding ideas. After reading the brief descriptions of
each technique, download the Brainstorm
Now file (a Word document), and begin brainstorming by answering the
questions asked you.
Explore
the evidence. Any
assertion you or others settle on requires a certain amount of evidence, be it
in the form of studies, facts, reasoning, personal anecdotes, or authoritative
quotations. First locate the assertion; then ask what evidence there is to
believe it. Assess the strength of this evidence. What issues or flaws are
associated with this evidence? How could it be stronger? Should you believe it?
Why or why not?
Look
beyond the obvious. Having an insight means to have an idea others don't
already see or realize themselves. We almost always have some obvious
observations about issues. Your job in writing an essay is to come up with
something new, something original and exciting. Your job is to tell the reader:
It's not about X. Instead, it is really about Y!
Identify assumptions. An assumption is any unstated
assertion that one assumes to be true, but which may actually not be true.
Every issue or problem has a few assumptions related to it. Usually these
assumptions are part of the reason why the problem is a problem in the first
place. Ask yourself what is being assumed in the topic or problem? What do
people take for granted to be true? What if this assumption were false?
Define
the problem. Figure out what the problem is. Until you figure this out, your
brainstorming won't have any direction or purpose. Ask yourself not only what
the problem is, but why it is indeed a problem. A problem for whom? When did it
first become a problem? What is the root of the problem?
Do
more research. If the ideas don't yet flow, perhaps you need to do more
research about the topic. Continue to educate yourself about the problem or
issue. Reading
up on it will soon give you the orientation needed to put you in the right
direction. As you get more knowledgeable about the topic, seek out longer, more
in-depth works, such as books in the library or articles on JSTOR.
Ask
questions. Write down ten questions about the problem or issue. They can
be any ten questions, just write them down (e.g., What caused X?, How is X
defined? What can X be compared to?). Asking these questions will generate
answers that may contain useful ideas. Some questions won't lead to fruitful
answers, but the few that do may lead you to a major insight that could form
the basis of your paper.
Carry
a notecard. Even when you're not consciously thinking about the topic, your
brain can be simmering away with the issue on a subconscious level. Keep a
notecard with you to record insights as they sporadically surface. When you
write down the insight, you teach your brain to produce more insights, and soon
by the end of the day your notecard will be full.
Write
in your Journal. Putting your thoughts into words allows you to think
more clearly about the issue or problem you're exploring. The written word
conjures up other words which in turn help spawn ideas about the topic. Write
about the problem in your journal, in your blog, or even on scrap paper. After
a while you will see that writing is a powerful tool for thinking. The pen or
keyboard takes you beyond what you can accomplish in silent meditation.
Examine
biases. Recognize that you have some unconscious biases in the way you view the
world around you. These biases could be social, economic, religious,
environmental, ethnic, or cultural predispositions that prevent you from seeing
the issue in another light. Ask yourself how a person from another walk of life
(a Buddhist monk in Nepal,
for example) might view the same problem. What about an elderly person, or a
child? An American versus an Egyptian? Step outside yourself.
|
|
Step 4: Thesis
After researching,
analyzing, and brainstorming, you should have an worthwhile insight to write
about. Now it's time to convert that worthwhile insight into a polished thesis
statement, which will then guide and shape the rest of the essay.
The thesis acts as the main claim of your paper,
and typically appears near the end of the introduction. Unless you have a
compelling reason to relocate the thesis from the traditional place, put it at
the end of your introductory paragraph. Readers anticipate and read closely
your thesis, and they want to find a polished statement there. The thesis
expresses in one concise sentence the point and purpose of your essay.
Make it arguable
Your thesis must make an arguable assertion. To
test whether your assertion is arguable, ask yourself whether it would be
possible to argue the opposite. If not, then it's not a thesis -- it's more of
a fact. For example:
- Not Arguable: "Computers are becoming an efficient mechanism for managing and transmitting information in large businesses." (Who's going to dispute this? It's not an arguable assertion -- it's a fact.)
- Arguable: "Heavy use of computers may disrupt family cohesion and increase divorce in society." (This is arguable because many people may not believe it. It would make a good thesis!)
Be specific
The thesis must also be specific.
Avoid broad, vague generalizations. Your thesis should include detail and
specificity, offering the reader the why behind your reasoning.
- Poor Specificity: "We should not pass the microchip bill." (Hey, not specific enough! It's just a value statement and doesn't provide enough reasoning for the reader.)
- Good Specificity: "Because the microchip insert causes serious health hazards such as cancer and brain tumors to those who use it, the microchip should not be passed." (Now the thesis is much more specific, and the reader gets a clear idea of what the essay is going to be about.)
Avoid lists
If your thesis consists of a long
list of points, your essay will most likely be superficial. Suppose you had six
reasons why WebCT should be adopted in college courses. Instead of trying to
cover so much ground in your essay, narrow your focus more to give greater
depth to fewer ideas, maybe discussing two or three points instead.
Long lists result in shallow
essays because you don't have space to fully explore an idea. If you don't
know what else to say about a point, do more brainstorming
and research.
However, if you're arguing a longer paper, and really need to cover this much
ground, still avoid the list in your thesis -- just give the reader a general
idea of your position, without being so specific.
- Example of a list: "The microchip bill biologically damages the health of children, invades the privacy of independent teenagers, increases crime, turns children against their parents, induces a sense of robotry about the individual, and finally, may result in the possible takeover of the government." (Wow, what a list! In a 1,000 word essay, each of these topics will only be explored superficially.)
- Narrower focus: "By surgically inserting circuitry similar to cell phone devices that has been known to cause headaches and fatigue, the microchip biologically endangers the health of children." (I've narrowed my focus to just one point -- health hazards -- instead of the six. Now my job will be to explore this assertion in depth. Academic writing almost always prefers depth over breadth.)
Follow an "although . . . actually" format
The
"although . . . actually" format is one of the most effective ways of
finding something original and controversial to say. In effect, you are telling
someone that what he or she thought to be previously true really isn't. You're
saying, Hey, you thought X? Well, you're wrong. Really, it's Y! Whenever
you look beyond the obvious and give readers something new to consider, you're
going to get their attention. Nothing works better than this "although . .
. actually" format to set you up in delivering an insight.
- Example: Although it appears that computers may help students learn to write, actually they can become a detriment to the generation of what what creative writers call "flow."
- Example: Although many people believe that extraterrestials and crop circles are a figment of the imagination, actually there is strong evidence suggested by collective, distinct anecdotes that alien encounters are real.
- Example: Although some philosophers profess to lead more pure, thoughtful lives, actually philosophers are no different than other publication-hungry academics.
(Note: "actually" isn't always
necessary. It is often implied with the clause "although.")
Step
5: Outline
Use
an outline to plan
Can you imagine a construction manager working on a
skyscraper without a set of blueprints? No way! Similarly, writers construct
essays using sets of blueprints or outlines to guide them in the writing
process. Of course writers don't have to use outlines, but the effect is
about the same as a construction worker who "freebuilds."
Drawing
up an outline allows you to think before you write. What use is there in
writing the entire paper only to realize that, had you done a little more
planning beforehand, you would have organized your essay in an entirely
different way? What if you realize later, after free-writing the essay, that
you should have omitted some paragraphs, restructured the progression of your
logic, and used more examples and other evidence?
You
can go back and try to insert major revisions into the essay, but the effect
may be like trying to add a thicker foundation to a building already
constructed. The outline allows you to think beforehand what you're going to
write so that when you do write it, if you've done your planning right, you
won't have to do as much rewriting. (You will still, of course, need to
revise.)
Make
your points brief
When
you construct your outline, keep it brief. The titles, headings, and points in
your outline should be about one line each. Remember that you are only drawing
an outline of the forest, not detailing each of the trees. Keep each line under
a dozen words. If you can't compress your point into a one-liner, you probably
don't have a clear grasp of what you're trying to say.
When
you describe the point of each paragraph, phrase the point in a mini-claim. If
the point of a paragraph is that soft drugs should be legal because they are
relatively harmless, don't just write "soft drugs" as the point
of the paragraph in your outline -- it's too brief and vague. Instead, write
"drugs should be legal b/c soft drugs are harmlessl." This
description is still brief, as it should be (one line or less), but it makes a
claim that gives it purpose in the outline.
Choose
an appropriate arrangement
Drawing
up an outline allows you to see at a glance how each of the paragraphs fits
into the larger picture. When looking at your paragraphs from this perspective,
you can easily shift around the order to see how a reorganization might be
better. Remember that each paragraph in the essay should support the position
or argument of your paper.
As
you're shifting paragraphs around (maybe like you would a Rubic's cube), you
will probably begin to wonder what the best arrangement really is. In general,
put what you want the reader to remember either first or last, not in the
middle. Studies in rhetoric have shown the readers remember least what is
presented in the middle of an essay. Hence, the middle is where you should
probably put your weaker arguments and counterarguments.
Some
writers urge a climactic arrangement, one that works up to your strongest
point, which is delivered as a kind of grand finale. Another successful
arrangement is the inductive argument, in which you build up the evidence
first, and then draw conclusions. A problem-solution format involves presenting
the problem first and then outlining the solution — this works well for some
topics because it is a soft version of the scientific method. Whatever your
choice, choose an arrangement that presents a clear, logical argument.
- See an Essay's General Structure (Word .doc)
Step
6: The Introduction
Get
the reader's attention
The
first goal in your introduction is to grab the reader's attention. Wake him or
her up and generate some interest about the topic. To grab the reader's
attention, you might present . . .
- an interesting fact
- a surprising piece of information
- an exciting quotation
- an intriguing paradox
- an explanation of an odd term
- a short narrative/anecdote (not fiction)
- a provocative question
See an example of
an attention-getting introduction.
Jump
right into the Issue
In
a short essay (under 1,000 words), a lengthy introduction is hardly needed.
After getting the reader's attention, just jump right into the issue and begin
directly, perhaps describing a specific, concrete situation -- presumably the context
of the problem you're exploring. Avoid beginning your essay with broad
statements or bland generalizations such as "X is becoming an issue . . .
" or "Throughout time man has wondered . . . ." Do not begin so
broad and general that the first several sentences could fit nearly any essay
in the world. For example:
- Too General: Crime has been an issue throughout time.
- More Specific: The question of the severity of punishments for juveniles is an issue that has garnered attention due to the increasing number of juvenile shootings in the last several years.
- Too General: Man has always wondered about the meaning of information.
- More Specific: The Age of Information brought about through the digital revolution of computers has posed significant questions about the value and worth of this information: Does having instant access to every newspaper and journal blog in the world make us more intelligent, value-based people?
I
like how Michele Montaigne, a sixteenth-century essayist, explains how to write
an introduction: "For me, who ask only to become wiser, not more learned
or eloquent, these logical and Aristotelian arrangements are not to the point.
I want a man to begin with the conclusion. I understand well enough what death
and pleasure are; let him not waste his time anatomizing them. I look for good
solid reasons from the start, which will instruct me in how to sustain their
attack. . . . I do not want a man to use his strength making me attentive and
to shout at me fifty times "Or oyez!" in the manner of our heralds. .
. . These are so many words lost on me. I come fully prepared from my house; I
need no allurement or sauce; I can perfectly well eat my meat quite raw; and
instead of whetting my appetite by these preparations and preliminaries, they
pall and weary it" ("Of Books").
In
other words, don't tire your reader with long introductions that fail to get
quickly to the point and issue. Begin with specifics and jump right into the
problem or conflict you are addressing. When readers see a good conflict, they
are likely to take an interest in it.
Present
your thesis
The
entire introduction should lead toward the presentation of your arguable
assertion, or thesis, whereby you take a stand on the issue you are discussing.
Deliver your thesis at the end of the introduction so that your reader knows
what general position you will take in your essay. You don't need to spell out
all the nitty gritty details of your thesis in the introduction, particularly
if it would be bulky and unintelligible to the reader who lacks all the ensuing
reference and context, but you should give the reader a good idea of what your
argument is. As you do this, avoid saying "I will discuss . . ." or
"I intend to argue . . ."
Step
7: Paragraphs
Choose
a singular focus
Each
paragraph should have a clear, singular focus to it. If there is an overriding
error students make in writing essays, it is shifting topics within the same
paragraph, rather than continuing to develop the same idea they began with. A
paragraph is a discrete unit of thought that expands one specific idea, not
three or four. If you find yourself shifting gears to start a new topic, begin
a new paragraph instead.
Someone
once compared the beginning of a new paragraph to the changing angle of a wall.
When the angle of the wall changes, a new wall begins. Let your paragraphs be
like that wall: running straight along a certain angle, and beginning anew when
the angle changes.
Begin
with a topic sentence
Nothing
will help you keep a tighter focus on your paragraphs than topic sentences. A
topic sentence is generally the first sentence of the paragraph, and it
describes the claim or point of the paragraph, thus orienting the reader to the
purpose of the paragraph. When you use topic sentences, your reader will
invariably find it easier to follow your thoughts and argument. As an example,
look at the first sentences of each paragraph on this page. The entire
paragraph is focused around the stated topic sentence. Additionally, headings
are used to make it even clearer and easier to follow. If you're writing a long
research essay (10 + pages), you might consider using headings.
Develop
the idea
Invariably
students shift topics and lose focus within their paragraphs because they do
not know how to adequately develop their ideas. They usually know the paragraph
needs to be longer, but they don't know how to expand their idea to fill that
length. Indeed a paragraph should be at least half a page long, but usually no
more than one page. How, then, if you don't have enough to say, do you fill
that paragraph length? Instead of broadening the focus, which will only be
another form of topic shifting, try implementing these techniques for
development:
- illustrate your idea with examples
- give an authoritative quotation
- anticipate and respond to counterarguments
- back your ideas with more evidence
- offer another perspective to the idea
- brainstorm more insights about the idea
- elaborate on causes/effects, definitions, comparison/contrasts
Step 8: The Conclusion
Recap your main idea
If your essay was long and
complex, sometimes difficult to follow, in the conclusion you'll want to recap
your ideas in a clear, summarizing manner. You want your readers to understand
the message you intended to communicate. However, if your essay was short and
simple, don't insult your readers by restating at length the ideas they already
understand. Strike a balance according to what you feel your readers need. In a
short essay (600 words or less), any recapitulation should be brief (about 2
sentences), and rephrased in a fresh way, not just cut and pasted from the
thesis.
Leave a memorable impression
It's not enough just to restate your main ideas --
if you only did that and then ended your essay, your conclusion would be flat
and boring. You've got to make a graceful exit from your essay by
leaving a memorable impression on the reader. You need to say something that
will continue to simmer in the reader's minds long after he or she has put down
your essay. To leave this memorable impression, try . . .
- giving a thought-provoking quotation
- describing a powerful image
- talking about consequences or implications
- stating what action needs to be done
- ending on an interesting twist of thought
- explaining why the topic is important
Keep it short
Keep your conclusion short, probably ten lines or
less, and avoid fluff. You're just trying to make a clever exit, and presumably
all the really important points have been made previously in your essay. You
should not introduce any totally new ideas in the conclusion; however, you
should not merely repeat your thesis either. This situation -- not presenting
anything new, and neither just sticking with the old -- at first seems to be a
paradox. However, with a little effort, one of the above six methods will
usually yield "a quiet zinger," as John Tribble calls it.
Examples of Real Conclusions
1. Ending on an image
Today, as the phonographs which follow prove, the
mystique of the cat is still very much alive in the Egyptian environment. For
after all, should not the cat be important in the Muslim world, as apparently
God inspired man to write its name-qi, t, t in Arabic letters-in such a shape
that it looks like a cat?
--Lorraine
Chittock, Cairo
Cats
2. Restating the thesis in a fresh way
If this book has any future use, it will be as a
modest contribution to that challenge, and as a warning: that systems of
thought like Orientalism, discourses of power, ideological fictions-mind-forg'd
manacles-are all too easily made, applied, and guarded. Above all, I hope to
have shown my reader that the answer to Orientalism is not Occidentalism. No
former "Oriental" will be comforted by the thought that having been
an Oriental himself he is likely-too likely-to study new
"Orientals"-or "Occidentals"-of his own making. If the
knowledge of Orientalism has any meaning, it is in being a reminder of the
seductive degradation of knowledge, of any knowledge, anywhere, at any time.
Now perhaps more than before.
--Orientalism, Edward Said
3. Ending on an image
When one reads any strongly individual piece of
writing, one has the impression of seeing a face somewhere behind the page. It
is not necessarily the actual face of the writer. I feel this very strongly
with Swift, with Defoe, with Fielding, Stendhal, Thackeray, Flaubert, though in
several case I do not know what these people looked like and do not want to
know. What one sees is the face that the writer ought to have. Well, in the case
of Dickens I see a face that is not quite the face of Dickens's photographs,
though it resembles it. It is the face of a man of about forty, with a small
beard and a high colour. He is laughing, with a touch of anger in his laughter,
but no triumph, no malignity. It is the face of a man who is always fighting
against something, but who fights in the open and is not frightened, the face
of a man who is generously angry-in other words, of a nineteenth-century
liberal, a free intelligence, a type hated with equal hatred by all the smelly
little orthodoxies which are now contending for our souls.
--"Charles Dickens," George Orwell
4. Ending on a quotation
A popular tale, which I picked up in Geneva
during the last years of World War I, tells of Miguel Servet's reply to the
inquisitors who had condemned him to the stake: "I will burn, but this is
a mere event. We shall continue our discussion in eternity."
--Jorge Luis Borges, Nonfictions
5. Moving towards the general
The practice of rhetoric involves a careful attention
to the characteristics and preferences of the audience for whom the writer
intends the message. Although Syfers' and Limpus' essays might be somewhat out
of place for a contemporary audience, in the 1970s they were not. However, as
argued throughout this essay, it is Syfers' memorable sarcasm and wit that
ultimately win over her audience. Being humorous while also driving home a
worthwhile point is a difficult feat to accomplish in writing. Because Syfers
accomplishes it so well, she seems to have stepped over the boundaries of time
and reached a much larger audience than she may have originally intended.
--imitation of a student essay
6. Talking about implications or consequences
I am quite convinced that what hinders progress
in the Arab world is the absence of a free press. The dirt in our society has
been swept under the carpet for too long. But I am certain that this won't be
the case for much longer. Arabs are beginning to engage in lively debate over
their political and social predicament. And Al-Jazeera offers a ray of hope.
Already, other Arab stations are imitating The Opposite Direction, though with
limitations. Press freedom leads to political freedom. Someday, in spite of the
attempts by today's totalitarian rulers, a free Arab press may help to create
real democracy in the Arab world.
--Fasial al-Kasim, "Crossfire: The Arab
Version"
Step 9: MLA Style
When
using ideas or phrases from other writers in your own essay, you must correctly
cite in your text exactly where the ideas or phrases come from. Correctly
identifying these ideas and phrases is called "in-text citation," and
the page at the end of your essay listing the sources you used is called a
"Works Cited" page.
Different
disciplines follow different style guides for in-text citation and Works Cited
pages, but in most writing courses, because they fall under the humanities
discipline, MLA (Modern Language Association) Style is used. Although there are
many details and rules about incorporating research into your essay, the following
five basic principles will help you correctly ingetrate sources in your essay.
1.
Make sure all authors cited in the body of your essay also appear on the Works
Cited page.
If
you quote Jones, Smith, and Johnson in your essay, these three authors should
appear with full documentation on the Works Cited pagel. Don't forget them.
Likewise, all the authors or sources listed in the Works Cited page should
appear in the body of your essay. There should be no sources listed on the
Works Cited page that were not cited in your actual essay.
2.
Only quote catchy or memorable phrases or sentences.
If
the source you're quoting is unremarkable and dry in its expression or opinion,
don't bring that unremarkable, dry text into your own writing as well.
Paraphrase this material instead, and follow up your paraphrase with the
author's name in parentheses (or the article title, if there is no author).
Only quote catchy, memorable, quotable phrases, and keep the quotations short
-- one or two lines usually. In general you want to quote sparingly and
preserve your own voice.
3.
Don't rely too much on the same source.
If
you have four or five quotes from the same author, your reader will eventually
just desire to read that author instead. Too much quoting also compromises your
own voice and sense of authority about the issue. Rather than limiting your
research to one or two authors, draw upon a wide variety of sources, and quote
only snippets from each. Having variety will ensure that you are well read in
the subject and that you've examined the issue from multiple perspectives.
4.
Follow up your quotations with commentary, interpretation, or analysis.
Avoid
just dropping in the quotation and then immediately moving on, assuming the
reader fully understands the meaning, purpose, and application of the quotation
just presented. You almost always should comment on the quotation in some way,
even if your commentary is a simple reexplanation of what the quotation means
("In other words . . ."). Remember that you're taking the quotation
from an article you've read, but the reader only gets a glimpse of that whole
article and lacks the context that you have, so it might be more difficult for
the reader to understand it. Because the essay is supposed to represent your
ideas, not just those of another, you must find some way to comment or analyze
what you summarize or quote.
5.
Use signal phrases to introduce your quotations.
A
signal phrase is a clause before the quotation that identifies the author
(e.g., "Jones says," or "According to Jones . . ."). Signal
phrases are essential to create a bridge between your own voice and that of
another you are incorporating into your essay. If you identify the author in
the signal phrase, don't also identify author in parentheses following the
quotation. Once is enough.
Also,
don't put the article title in the signal phrase unless you want to draw
particular attention it. Including the article title in your signal phrase
usually results in a long, clunky pre-quote phrase that takes the focus off the
quotation.
- Example of a clunky pre-quote
signal phrase:
According to the article "Censorship in American High School Reading Classes," Twain's Huckleberry Finn has been "sacrificed to the gods of political correctness, without any attention to its literary merits." (Avoid putting the article title in the signal phrase.) - Better: According to the American Quarterly Review, Twain's Huckleberry Finn has been "sacrificed to the gods of political correctness, without any attention to its literary merits."
- Even Better: According to Edmund Wilson, "Twain rewrote the American setting through his character Huck Finn."
- Example of redundancy: Mark Twain says the secret to success is "making your vocation your vacation" (Twain.) (We don't need Twain identified twice!)
Special
note--"qtd. in": Suppose you're using a quotation that appears inside
an article written by someone other than the one saying the quotation. In other
words, if you're using, say, Judge William's quotation that appears within Mary
Jones' article, you cite it by writing "qtd. in" following the quote.
If so, write "qtd. in Jones," or whomever.
- Example: According to Judge Williams, "just law is the foundation of a just society" (qtd. in Jones).
If
Jones is just paraphrasing Williams, then you would omit the "qtd.
in" and just write (Jones).
Practice:
Read Diana Hacker's sample research essay and identify as many
instances as you can where the above five principles are used.
Step
9a: Citation
Quick Jump Menu
|
|
There are three main ways to integrate quotations
into your essay: (1) direct quotation, (2) paraphrase, and (3) mixed quotation.
You should usually paraphrase the material, and only directly quote it or give
a mixed quotation when the phrasing of the quotation is interesting or catchy
in some pleasing way -- quote when the text is quotable, in other words (like
the quotation on the homepage of this site).
Direct quotation
involves quoting word for word one or more sentences from an author or source.
When you quote, be sure to introduce your quotation with a signal phrase. A signal phrase is a clause that lets the reader know who the
author or source is. In the following examples of direct quotation, note how
the signal phrases precede the quotations:
- According to Karl Menninger, a Freudian psychoanalyst, "the wish to kill, unexpectedly robbed of certain external occasions or objects of unconscious gratification, may be turned back upon the person of the wisher and carried into effect as suicide" (54). (Notice how the phrase "a Freudian psychoanalyst" explains who Menninger is. Phrases that rename their subjects like this must always be enclosed in commas.)
- Menninger says that "suicide occurs when an individual thus treats himself as an external object, frequently identified with the very object toward which his love and hate, particularly his unconscious wish to kill, had been directed" (55). (The inclusion of the word "that" allows you to omit the comma. If you don't use "that," however, then you would need the comma.)
- Menninger says, "In Catholic countries there is usually a higher homicide rate, a lower suicide rate; in Protestant countries a higher suicide and lower homicide rate" (61). (The number in parentheses indicates what page the quotation is on. If your source doesn't have page numbers (e.g., a website), then do not invent any page or paragraph numbers here.)
2. Paraphrase
Paraphrase, instead of
quoting the author word for word, involves putting the original phrasing into
your own words. Be careful to substantially reword the original, however. If
you leave just several words in a row unchanged, it will be considered
plagiarism -- because you're essentially stealing someone else's phrasing.
As far as signal
phrases and paraphrasing go, when you paraphrase you can choose whether or not
to use a signal phrase. If you do not use a signal phrase, you must identify
the author in parentheses following the paraphrase. Here are a few examples:
- Freudian psychoanalyst Karl Menninger says that people who are deprived of the ability to kill others usually end up turning their murderous anger back upon themselves to commit suicide (54). (Notice how I've totally reworded this from the previous section. The rewording is my own phrasing.)
- Suicide occurs when an individual redirects his initially outward-directed hatred back upon himself (Menninger 55). (Notice that there is no signal phrase here, so I have identified the author in parentheses following the paraphrase.)
- Menninger explains that Catholic countries report higher rates of homicide and lower rates of suicide, while Protestant countries report the reverse: more suicides and less homicides (61). (Notice that the author is identified in the signal phrase, so I don't need to identify him again in the parentheses following the paraphrase.)
3. Mixed Quotations
Mixed quotations are a mix between direct
quotation and paraphrase. Mixed quotations involve paraphrasing half of the
original but mixing in a few direct selections from the author. When you insert
mixed quotations, be sure to blend in the quotation with the grammar of your
own sentence. The sentence as a whole must flow smoothly.
To achieve this smooth flow with mixed
quotations, you may need to omit or add words from or to the original. To omit
words, insert an ellipses . . . in place of the words you take out.
Ellipses always indicate omission. To add words, insert them inside brackets
[ ] to indicate the insertion. Notice that there are spaces between the
ellipses dots and that the brackets are square, not rounded like parentheses.
- e.e. Cummings asserted that the poet's imagination and his "preoccupation with the Verb" results in an ability to surpass normal standards of logic and create "an irresistible truth [in which] 2 x 2 = 5" (34). (Notice that the words "in which" inside brackets are my own insertion. I needed to add them so that the sentence would flow grammatically.)
- B.F. Skinner, a social constructionist, believes that our behavior is "a genetic endowment traceable to the evolutionary history of the species" and that whatever predispositions or character we have developed, it is a consequence of our environmental immersion rather than innate character (78). (I chose to quote partially here to be accurate with Skinner's definition, but I didn't want to quote too much from Skinner because his writing may be difficult for my audience to understand.)
- Poet Wallace Stevens, when asked about his literary influences, explained that he was "not conscious of having been influenced by anybody and ha[d] purposely held off from reading . . . Eliot and Pound" in order to refrain from unconsciously imitating their works and ruining his originality (234). (Note the ellipses. I omitted several words to shorten the quotation around the essential point I wanted to communicate. I also had to change "have" to "had," and so wrote ha[d] to indicate the alteration..)
Plagiarism
Plagiarism --
its original meaning, "to kidnap" -- is a serious academic offense
that can result in your failure of the course and possible suspension from the
university. It is important that you know what plagiarism entails so that you
can avoid the consequences. Ignorance is no excuse.
In short, plagiarism
occurs whenever a student attempts to pass off someone else's ideas or phrasing
as his or her own, rather than giving due credit to the author. Even if the
student mentions the source, if he or she fails to put quotation marks around
phrasing not his or her own, it is considered plagiarism, because the student
is attempting to pass off phrasing that does not belong to him or her.
You can learn more
about plagiarism in two easy ways:
- Take this excellent ten question plagiarism quiz prepared by Indiana University. Highly recommended!
- Read about plagiarism from AUC's Academic Integrity site.
I have compiled a number of websites,
Word documents, and Powerpoints on MLA style, created by different
instructors and organizations who present the complexities of in-text citation
and works cited.
You can also do some practices
with in-text citation.
Step 10: Language
According to Truman
Capote, "The greatest pleasure of writing is not what it's about, but the
music the words make." As you edit the language of your essay, you are
trying to make music out of the words.
In this step the content of your
essay should be solid. If the idea itself needs discarding, you shouldn't be
tweaking the language; it would be a waste of time working on transitions if
the organization and structure of your essay were in need of repair. Hence
editing the language of your essay comes last. Here you are putting polish on a
shoe that has already been sewn.
Editing the language can be
tedious, but it is essential. You've got to proofread your essays dozens of
times to catch all the rough spots and language errors. As you proofread you
will be checking for misspellings, poor mechanics, bad grammar, awkward word
flow and numerous other linguistic details that you can improve. Proofreading
the language may take hours as you attempt to polish your language to the point
that it is pleasing to read and has literary style.
Give Your
Eyes Rest
The more you
read your essay, the more blind you become to it. Soon you stop reading the
words on the page and only begin reading what's in your mind, which you falsely
transpose onto the page. The actual letters could be Hebrew, or Greek, for all
it matters at that point.
Don't keep reading hour after hour until your
mind registers the entire text at a glance, without seeing the details. What
you must do is rest your eyes; take a break. Give yourself a day or two between
revisions. (This is why you should not procrastinate your assignments.) When
you come back to your essay with fresh eyes and a renewed perspective, you will
see with added clarity all the rough phrasings and strange ideas that your eyes
once glided over.
Know What to Look For
You can read your essay a thousand times over,
but if you don't know what you're looking for, you will probably miss all the
errors you're attempting to find. If you're going to work hard, make sure
you're putting all your energy to a productive use. Know what to look for when
you proofread. See the criteria in the Grades section
of this site. There are twelve areas to look for: logic, evidence, development,
focus, structure, unity, integration, in-text citation, works cited, grammar,
clarity, style. Check off each category as you examine your essay. Another help
for proofreading is to ask yourself the same questions in the Peer Review,
conducting instead a "self-review." Finally, be sure to use the spell-checker
and grammar-checker in Word.
Don't Plagiarize
You might want to ask a friend to read over your
essay and give suggestions for change. This is usually advantageous. Some
students, however, perhaps feeling pressure to bring their language level up to
a more fluent, "A" level, might ask their friends to go beyond a few
simple suggestions and instead to heavily edit or rewrite the language of their
paper. While it is generally okay for another to get some feedback from
others on ideas and language, your friend or family member cannot take upon the
role of an editor, changing your sentences and thoughts to reflect a linguistic
and analytical level that is not yours and which is beyond your ability.
Passing off another's language as your own -- even if the ideas remain original
to your own mind -- is considered plagiarism.
Your work must be your own, and that includes the language and style, not just
content.
Knowing that the work is your own, and that it
represents your highest level of performance, you will feel a sense of
achievement and personal growth that perhaps you have not experienced before.
Each essay should seem to you that it is your best work to date. Only when you
feel this way is the paper done.
Continue on to editing your language for clarity,
style, and grammar.
Stage 10a: Clarity
Quick Jump Menu
|
|
Use topic sentences
Few techniques add more clarity
to your writing than well-formed topic sentences. Topic sentences usually
appear at or near the beginning of each paragraph and tell the reader what the
topic of the paragraph will be. Using topic sentences to "signpost"
your meaning will orient the reader and help him or her follow comfortably
along your path of thought.
You
will discover that when a writer uses topic sentences, you can skim the entire
essay and still understand the main points. The next time you read a long
essay, try reading only the first one or two sentences of each paragraph. You
will rarely be lost or confused if the topic sentences make clear what the
purpose of each paragraph is.
- Follow along this sample essay to see an example of topic sentences.
- Then, Practice with topic sentences
Make clear transitions
Transitions act as bridges
between your paragraphs. Since each paragraph offers a distinct thought, you
need to connect these two distinct thoughts in some logical way for the reader.
The transitions supply the logic of how two paragraphs connect, how one idea
leads to the next, or how the two are related. Don't make the reader guess how
one paragraph relates to the other. The following are some common patterns for
transitions:
- Not only is vegetarianism unhealthy for the human body, vegetariarism also creates an excess of pesticides in the environment. (Here I'm transitioning from health hazards to environmental hazards.)
- In addition to problems of obesity, America's youth also suffer from increasing amounts of psychological stress. (Here I'm transitioning from obesity to psychological stress.)
- Besides violating the right to privacy, the microchip also puts children at danger in the even of information-hacking. (Here I'm transitioning from privacy to information-hacking.)
Omit needless words
"Omit needless words!"
"Omit needless words!" This was the constant advice, says E.B. White,
of his former professor, William Strunk. White says Strunk would occasionally
grab a student by the lapels and shout this phrase several times, but then be
almost restricted from elaborating more for fear of violating the very
principle he was teaching. Omit needless words, write with concision, make
your sentences succinct, cut out the fat, remove the deadwood, make every word
pull its own weight -- these common phrases are all intended to convince
students to streamline their prose with more efficiency and power by removing
unnecessary words.
In Strunk's own words,
"Vigorous writing is concise. A sentence should contain no unnecessary
words, a paragraph no unnecessary sentences, for the same reason that a drawing
should have no unnecessary lines and a machine no unnecessary parts." In other
words, if you bought a new car and looked under the hood, you would be appalled
to see unnecessary, functionless parts. Similarly in an essay, all sentences
and paragraphs must have an essential function and purpose.
Concision can also be understood through
the metaphor of dilution. A word by itself has a sense of power, but when
combined with other words, the power of that word is diluted by the presence of
the other words, each of which is fighting for the reader's attention. If you
want to focus the reader's attention, don't dilute your best words with
unnecessary phrases and elaborations. In this way, more can be less.
- Needless Words:A good basketball player is not necessarily one who is tall and dominating on the floor, or who has more height than the other players (e.g., 6'7" and above), but rather one who is keen enough to perceive strengths and weaknesses on the court, can see mismatches, liabilities, weak spots, and knows as well how to capitalize on his or her own strengths, be they speed, quickness, or explosive driving power.
- Concise: A good basketball player is not necessarily one who is tall and dominating, but rather one who can perceive strengths and weaknesses on the court, can see mismatches, liabilities, weak spots, and knows as well how to capitalize on his or her own strengths, be they speed, quickness, or explosive driving power.
- Super Concise: A good basketball player needs prudence more than height.
- Needless Words: Rugby players must be fully prepared and always ready to immolate their almost already war-torn bodies in sacrifice, in diving ruthlessly for the leather ball, blocking with their arms extended and their legs firmly planted on the ground, always moving with tenacity and vigor and enthusiasm across the expansive green lawn, for the good of the team and the honor of the sport itself. Long live the Queen!
- Concise: Rugby players must be fully prepared to immolate their bodies in sacrifice, in diving ruthlessly for the ball, blocking with their arms extended and their legs firmly planted, always moving with tenacity and vigor across the expansive green lawn, for the good of the team and the honor of the sport itself.
- Super Concise: Rugby players sacrifice their bodies for the game.
Establish emphasis
Subordination
and coordination allow you to emphasize different parts of the sentence,
so that the more important phrase is clear. Choosing between subordinate or
coordinate clauses alerts you to the hierarchical relationships between
information in your sentences and allows you to stress or emphasize certain
ideas more than others.
Coordination
involves combining clauses in a way that puts them on equal footing, where
neither clause is more emphasized than the other. Coordinate clauses are joined
with one of the seven coordinating conjunctions -- and, but, or, for, so, nor,
yet. On the other hand, subordination (like it's root, subordinate) involves
designating one clause to be more important than the other. Subordinate clauses
usually begin with although, while, or because.
- Subordinating Clauses: Although the train improved mobility and efficiency of travel, it put many cowboys out of work. (The red clause is subordinate; it does not have as much emphasis as the cowboy clause.)
- Coordinating Clauses: The train improved the mobility and efficiency of travel, and it put many cowboys out of work. (Both clauses have equal emphasis.)
- Subordinating Clauses: Even though many cowboys were out of work, they began a new culture of city dwelling that drew them together with social strength. (The red clause has less emphasis.)
- Coordinating Clauses: Many cowboys were out of work, but they began a new culture of city dwelling that drew them together with social strength.
- Subordinating Clauses: While many thought the cowboy era was over, the new city cowboys proved to be a vital, powerful force in American unpopular culture. (The red clause has less emphasis.)
- Coordinating Clauses: Many thought the cowboy era was over, yet the new city cowboys proved to be a vital, powerful force in American unpopular culture.
Use Rhythm
If you really want to get fancy with emphasis,
you can experiment with periodic and cumulative sentences. Periodic and
cumulative sentences are two advanced options for creating a strong sense of
rhythm and emphasis in your sentence. The periodic sentence is one in which the
main clause is considerably delayed, whereas the cumulative sentence opens
quickly with the main clause, and then adds on multiple nonrestrictive clauses
after it.
- Periodic sentence: Sigmund Freud, a German psychologist born in the late nineteenth century, and famous for his controversial theories about early-childhood psychological formation and other adult disorders, including suicide, patricide, and matricide, omitted essential data formulating his theories.
- Cumulative sentence: Sigmund Freud omitted essential data when formulating his theories, which involved explanations for early-childhood psychological formation and other adult disorders, including suicide, patricide, and matricide, which he developed in the early twentieth century in Germany, where he was born.
- Periodic sentence: Apparently Coca-Cola, which is currently used by its own manufacturers to clean out the engines of their trucks, as well as remove toilet stains, purify the stomach of questionable bacteria, and marinate steak in several hours (frightening facts about a substance harmlessly and thoughtlessly consumed by millions of people around the world), originally it was laced with cocaine.
- Cumulative sentence: Apparently Coca-Cola once contained cocaine, which in the early twentieth century was not thought to be harmful taken in small doses, especially when the dose was only 1/1400 of a grain per bottle, hardly something to give one a heavy addiction, yet still strong enough to mildly lure one to consuming the soda, which was not so different from various medicines at the time, also containing slight trace amounts of cocaine, practically unavoidable byproducts from cocoa leaves.
- Cumulative: "I wish I could give you fresh material, but I can't," said Max King, another classmate, who went on to edit The Philadelphia Inquirer and now, by coincidence, is president of the Heinz Endowments, the wealthy Pittsburgh charity of which Mr. Kerry's wife, Teresa, is the chairwoman. (The New York Times, 16 May 2004, "Prep School Peers Found Kerry Talented, Ambitious, and Apart.")
Beyond any of the above
techniques, you can increase the clarity of your writing by practicing a
general straightforwardness in the expression of your ideas. Look over your
sentences and ask yourself whether they communicate their ideas in the clearest
way possible. You may want to pretend that a twelve-year-old will be reading
your text. Will he understand what you're talking about? Remember that while
your reader may possess more sophistication than a young child, you don't want
to make the reader struggle to follow your ideas. Keep your meaning simple and
easy to understand.
To really be clear, you might try
talking out your sentences. Imagine yourself saying what you've written to a
friend sitting beside you. If you can imagine yourself speaking to your friend
with the same sentences you've written, chances are your writing is probably
clear and easy to follow. On the other hand, if you can't see yourself saying
what you've written to anyone, consider revising it to make it more readable.
Go back and revise your sentences to make them friendlier, clearer, more
straightforward.
Step 10b: Style
Your
style is the fingerprint of your writing and consists of a number of comprising
elements. As you edit your essay for style, pay attention to these six areas:
Avoid
Personal References
Avoid
using personal references such as "I" or "In my opinion."
It is very easy to say "I feel" or "I think," but this adds
little to your essay except a weak argument. If your sentence reads, "I
think the Internet is a great source of information," what do the words
"I think" add? Rather than supplying a reason for the Internet being
a great source of information, the reason given here is "because I think
so."
In
addition to providing a weak argument, using "I" also takes the focus
off the subject and places it on you, the writer, which is sometimes desired in
creative writing, but undesirable in an academic essay where the focus is
supposed to be on a specific topic. You can usually recast your sentence in a
way that omits personal references, but if the sentence just doesn't sound
right without "I," then leave it in. It's better to be self-centered
than unreadable.
- Personal References: In my opinion, gay marriage threatens the institution of marriage and the essential structure of the family, which is the fabric of society.
- Revised: Gay marriage threatens the institution of marriage and the essential structure of the family, which is the fabric of society.
- Personal References: I think that society is held together by allowing individuals to live as they which, not by constricting laws.
- Revised: Society is held together by allowing individuals to live as they which, not by constricting laws.
Diction:
Choose the right words
Students
learning to use a thesaurus often use it excessively and incorrectly in their
selection of words. Knowing that all synonyms do not mean the same thing --
that each synonym has a subtle nuance of meaning making it distinct from the
other words -- will help you avoid random substitutions of words that merely
seem to look better. Using good diction in your essay involves choosing exactly
the right word for the meaning you want. If you're unsure of a word's meaning,
look it up in an online dictionary
or download
a dictionary to your computer.
- Poor Diction: Devlin's essay predicates that a society consists of a group of people brought together by a common set of morals and assurances.
- Better Diction: Devlin's essay asserts that a society consists of a group of people brought together by a common set of morals and beliefs.
- Poor Diction: Hart responds that Devlin's essay is nothing more than a babble and malentendu of what a society is.
- Better Diction: Hart responds that Devlin's essay is nothing more than a confusion and misunderstanding of what a society is.
Vary
your sentence length
"Choppiness"
is the effect of multiple short sentences in a row giving a sense of
breathlessness and childlike simplicity. Contrastingly, the opposite --
multiple, successive elongated sentences one after another -- gives a sense of
never-ending lung power and pompous sophistication. A short sentence can be a
good option for the content you're writing, just as a long one can as well. The
key is to mix them up so that you have some short sentences and some
long alternating with each other. This variety will give rhythm to your prose.
- Choppy sentences: John turned on the computer. He opened Framemaker. He selected a new document. The document was blank. He opened the graphics panel. He chose the shape tool. It was a polygon. He filled the polygon with red shading. He put a black border on it. It was a nice day. His mother brought him sandwiches. The sandwiches tasted good. (Holy Smokes! I could not take more than about half a page of this before I would go crazy!)
- Over-elongated sentences: Turning on the computer, John opened Framemaker and, after selecting a blank document and opening the graphics panel, chose a polygonal shape tool which he filled with red shading and a black border while his mother brought him sandwiches, all of which contributed to him having a nice day. Then, deliberating between a black and white or a color layout, John decided that for a publication that would be on the web as well as in print, he would need to create both types of documents, because the print would be too costly for color photos, while the web would be too dull for merely black and white, but this color vs. non-color dilemma was only the tip of the iceberg for John in Framemaker, for he knew neither how to create anchored frames for his graphics, nor how to manipulate the sizes and resolutions of the photos he wanted to import, which was giving him a headache, despite his mother's nice sandwiches. (Combining sentences is fun up to a point, and then it gets ridiculous.)
- Perfect mix of short and long: After turning on the computer, John opened Framemaker and selected a blank document. He then opened the graphics panel, chose a polygonal shape tool, and filled it with red shading and a black border. His mother brought him sandwiches, which made his day nice. Then, deliberating between a black and white or a color layout, John decided that for a publication that would be on the web as well as in print, he would need to create both types of documents. The print would be too costly for color photos, while the web would be too dull for merely black and white. But this color . . . (You get the point by now--variety leads to a pleasing rhythm.)
Avoid
sexist pronouns
Although
in the past it was acceptable to use "he" when referring to both men
and women, it is no longer acceptable to do so now. Why? Because linguists
found that language use actually does have an impact on the way people think
and act. If pronouns are always "he," and certain professions are
always fireman, policeman, chairman, congressmen,
etc, then it is more likely that men -- by simple virtue of the privileged
masculine pronoun and noun use -- will fill those positions, and that women
will feel that they do not belong in them. Avoiding sexist pronouns will help
you find liberation from these restricting gender roles.
Even if you disagree with the above
theory, using "he" only pronouns is a practice that is no longer
tolerated in MLA style. You should instead choose to pluralize your subject and
use "they" or "their" when referring back to that subject.
Or you can choose "he or she," but if you need to write "he or
she" more than twice in the sentence, you might give your reader a
headache. Try to avoid "s/he" or "he/she" simply because it
is unsightly. Really the best solution is pluralization. (When implementing the
plural solution, remember the principle of agreement.
"Everyone needs their umbrella" is not grammatical, because
"everyone" is a singular subject.)
- Sexist: If a medical student wants to succeed, he has to learn to budget his time wisely.
- Liberated: If medical students want to succeed, they have to learn to budget his time wisely.
- Sexist: If one wants to become a DJ, he has to be familiar with the current music styles and have a strong sense of internal rhythm and musical flow.
- Liberated: If one wants to become a DJ, he or she has to be familiar with the current music styles and have a strong sense of internal rhythm and musical flow.
- Sexist: A good computer programmer has to root his knowledge in practical experience.
- Liberated: Good computer programmers have to root their knowledge in practical experience.
Maintain
a level of formality
Just
as in in daily life, in writing you naturally adjust the level of formality of
your writing style to the situation and audience. You may use one level of
formality with your teacher, and another level with your best friend. In an
academic essay, be sure to maintain a formal voice. One way to adjust your
level of formality is by avoiding contractions (i.e., using "do not"
instead of "don't"). However, it is acceptable to use contractions if
you desire to.
- Hyper-formal: The degree to which private controversial moralities are decriminalized by the federal government depends on the extent of their injurious repercussions on an otherwise benign society.
- Too informal: The feds will start putting pervs and whores in the slammer if they feel their smutty actions are mixin' up good men and women.
- Just right: Whether private immoralities are outlawed by the government or not depends on the harm they inflict on public society.
Avoid
emotionalism
In
addition to a formal voice, you should also maintain a cool-headed, objective
tone. Tone usually becomes an issue when you are writing about hot topics you
feel strongly about -- religion, for example, or cultural values. Even when you
strongly disagree with an idea, avoid getting "emotional" in your
expression. Avoid seeming angry, or condescending, or rude. Keep your calm and
remain scholarly, and try to portray yourself as one who is objectively
assessing the situation.
- Emotional: We must do everything we can to legalize gay marriage. For the sake of equality, the rights of liberty and freedom that our forefathers fought for--it is essential!!! Don't let conservatives take over your government and impose their puritanical moral values on everyone. This is only going to lead to dozens of more restrictions that those white-haired conservatives will impose in their cozy congress seats!
- Objective: Keeping gay marriage illegal poses significant questions about the constitutionality of such laws. The forefathers who wrote the Constitution believed an individual's freedom was vitally important, and that as long as the actions did not cause directly harm to society, the actions should not be decriminalized.
Step
10c: Grammar
As
you edit the grammar of your essay, you should particularly focus on the
grammar concepts that your teacher has previously marked on your papers. For
example, if your teacher has written "run-on" on your previous
papers, especially look at the following instruction on run-ons and then look
carefully over your essay to make sure you're avoiding them. You should also be
familiar with all the rest of the grammar concepts here and be sure that your
essay is grammatically correct. If a term below looks unfamiliar, learn it.
Although a grammatically perfect essay won't mean that the essay is also
perfect, a teacher is less apt to give you a poor grade if he or she is unable
to justify that grade with grammatical errors. In the minds of many old
fashioned teachers, perfect grammar equals a perfect essay. When you're done
editing for grammar, and you've proofread your essay a dozen times, you're
done. Congratulations!
Colons: Use a colon for three main reasons: (1) to introduce
a list, (2) to introduce a quotation, or (3) to set up a second clause that
answers the first. The one main rule with colons is that an independent clause
must precede the colon.
- They looked up at the constellations and could see a multitude of different patterns Orion, the Big Dipper, Cassiopia, and the Bear.
- Correction: They looked up at the constellations and could see a multitude of different patterns: Orion, the Big Dipper, Cassiopia, and the Bear.
- When Frank was confident he had Sally's respect, he asked her a big question "Will you marry me?"
- Correction: Frank was confident he had Sally's respect, he asked her a big question: "Will you marry me?"
- Sally answered briefly and softly: "Love is like an ocean wave. It rolls into shore from seemingly nowhere."
- Correction: Sally answered briefly and softly: "Love is like an ocean wave: it rolls into shore from seemingly nowhere."
Semi-colons: If two independent clauses are closely related,
you can join the clauses with a semi-colon rather than a comma and coordinating
conjunction. You must be be sure, however, that independent clauses are on both
sides of the semi-colon.
- Frank asked Sally out for a date that night she accepted enthusiastically.
- Correction: Frank asked Sally out for a date that night; she accepted enthusiastically.
- Sally didn't know what to wear all, her clothes were torn and ratty.
- Correction: Sally didn't know what to wear; all her clothes were torn and ratty.
Commas: In general, use a comma wherever you want to insert
a light, natural pause. There are also specific rules to guide you in placing
commas.
1. Use a comma after an introductory clause.
- When Sally opened her eyes and looked around her she thought she was in a dream.
- Correction: When Sally opened her eyes and looked around her, she thought she was in a dream.
- Seeing Sally return to full composure Frank asked if he might have a sandwich.
- Correction: Seeing Sally return to full composure, Frank asked if he might have a sandwich.
2. Use commas to set off non-restrictive clauses or
parenthetical expressions. (A non-restrictive clause is a clause that doesn't
restrict the sentence's meaning -- it can be dropped without changing the
meaning.)
- The sandwich which was pickle and peanut butter with ketchup mixed in looked repulsive to Frank and made him almost vomit.
- Correction: The sandwich, which was pickle and peanut butter with ketchup mixed in, looked repulsive to Frank and made him feel ill.
- Sally who grew up in a small farm town in Nebraska said that's how everyone eats his or her sandwich.
- Correction: Sally, who grew up in a small farm town in Nebraska, said that's how everyone eats his or her sandwich.
3. When joining two independent clauses with a coordinating
conjunction (and, but, or, for, so, nor, yet), put a comma before the
coordinating conjunction. (Note: an independent clause is a clause that can
stand alone as a full sentence.)
- Frank said to nevermind about the sandwich because he wasn't hungry and he proceeded to lay down beside Sally.
- Correction: Frank said to nevermind about the sandwich because he wasn't hungry, and he proceeded to lay down beside Sally.
- Sally asked if Frank came to the beach often and he said today was in fact the first time he had ever visited the place.
- Correction: Sally asked if Frank came to the beach often, and he said today was in fact the first time he had ever visited the place.
Misplaced Modifiers: A misplaced modifier occurs when
a clause is incorrectly placed in a sentence such that it appears to modify the
wrong word.
- Recovering slowly, the fainting spell that Sally experienced gradually diminished. (The fainting spell didn't recover slowly--Sally did!)
- Correction: Recovering slowly, Sally gradually returned from her fainting spell.
- Ever worried, Frank quickly ran towards Sally, very concerned about helping her. (Sally isn't very concerned--Frank is!)
- Correction: Ever worried and very concerned about helping her, Frank quickly ran towards Sally.
Tense Shifts: A tense shift occurs when a verb breaks the
unity of the other tenses in the sentence. Be especially careful of shifting
between past and present tenses with your verbs.
- When Frank saw Sally sitting on her picnic blanket, his jaw drops and his eyes get all wide.
- Correction: When Frank saw Sally sitting on her picnic blanket, his jaw dropped and his eyes got all wide.
- Upon seeing Frank stand nobly above his glorious sandcastle, Sally fainted and had fallen backwards onto the ground.
- Correction: Upon seeing Frank stand nobly above his sandcastle, she fainted and fell backwards onto the ground.
Capitalization: Capitalize words that are specific names. Do
not capitalize a word just to give it emphasis.
- st. petersberg beach is a place where many a love has been ignited, according to local Professors.
- Correction: St. Petersberg Beach is a place where many a love has been ignited, according to local professors.
- According to shakespeare's romeo and juliet, the Truest love is frequently a star-crossed love.
- Correction: According to Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, the truest love is frequently a star-crossed love.
Possessives: To indicate possession, use an apostrophe
before an "s." To indicate possession for a plural subject, add an
apostrophe after the "s."
- Sallys hair needed washing.
- Correction: Sally's hair needed washing.
- Ones need for companionship is second only to ones need for food.
- Correction: One's need for companionship is second only to one's need for food.
- The lifeguards tower chairs were empty due to the lack of people on the beach.
- Correction: The lifeguard's tower chairs were empty due to the lack of people on the beach.
Pronoun Agreement: Pronoun agreement errors occur when the
pronoun and the corresponding subject do not match up. Plural subjects have
plural pronouns, and singular subjects have singular pronouns.
- If a boy wants to impress a girl, they better do more than build sandcastles.
- Correction: If a boy wants to impress a girl, he better do more than build sandcastles.
- When someone is lonely, they usually go on a picnic.
- Correction: When someone is lonely, he or she usually goes on a picnic.
Note: The following pronouns are singular pronouns: anyone,
everyone, whoever, someone, no one, nobody.
Subject-verb Agreement: Subject-verb agreement errors occur
when the subject doesn't match up correctly with the verb. Usually the error
occurs when the subject is singular and the verb is plural, or when the subject
is plural and the verb singular.
- Sally's took out the biscuits, butter, and jam that was in her basket.
- Correction: Sally took out the biscuits, butter, and jam that were in her basket.
- Frank made a sandcastle, along with a surrounding moat and turret, that was very eye-catching.
- Correction: Frank made a sandcastle, along with a surrounding moat and turret, that were very eye-catching.
Run-ons: There are two types of run-on sentences: fused
sentences and comma splices. A fused sentence occurs when two sentences
are fused or blended into one, without any punctuation. A comma splice occurs
when two independent clauses are joined together with only a comma, rather than
with a comma and a coordinating conjunction. A comma is not sufficient to join
two independent clauses. You must use a comma and a coordinating
conjunction (and, but, or, for, so, nor, yet).
- Frank was an orphan from Kentucky he didn't have any parents and lived in a foster home.
- Correction: Frank was an orphan from Kentucky. He didn't have any parents and lived in a foster home.
- He liked to spend his days at the beach no one bothered him there.
- Correction: He liked to spend his days at the beach. No one bothered him there.
- Sally went to the beach, she had a picnic there.
- Correction: Sally went to the beach, and she had a picnic there.
- The weather at the beach was rather windy, you had to keep a hold of your hat or it would blow off.
- Correction: The weather at the beach was rather windy, so you had to keep a hold of your hat or it would blow off.
Fragments: Fragments are incomplete sentences that
lack a subject or verb. Or, if the sentence does seem to have a subject or
verb, the subject and verb appear in a subordinate clause rather than the main,
independent clause.
- Swam in the ocean. (no subject)
- Frank in the ocean. (no verb)
- Frank swimming in the ocean. (not an independent clause)
- Correction: Frank swam in the ocean.
Fragments are harder to spot when they are next to real
sentences, but they are still fragments.
- Frank went to the beach. Swam in the ocean.
- Correction: Frank went to the beach and swam in the ocean.
- It was the last thing I thought I'd see. Frank in the ocean.
- Correction: The last thing I thought I'd see was Frank in the ocean.
- There are a few things I hate. Frank swimming in the ocean.
- Correction: There are a few things I hate. Frank swimming in the ocean is one of them.